Unveiling Pro-Russian Narratives: A Study of Media Propaganda Amidst the Ukraine Conflict (Insights from the Slovak Context)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51698/tripodos.2024.56.06Keywords:
Military conflict, Ukraine, narrative, disinformation, Russia, SlovakiaAbstract
In light of Slovakia commemorating 20 years since its accession to the EU and NATO in 2024, it is foreseeable that new disinformation narratives will emerge, becoming significant aspects of societal and political discourse. Therefore, there is an urgent need for research on narratives surrounding the current presentation of the military conflict in Ukraine. Utilizing qualitative content analysis, our study concentrates on identifying the most dominant narratives related to the military conflict in Ukraine, given its proximity as the eastern neighbor of post-communist Slovakia. We conducted our research within the framework of five of the most popular pro-Russian disinformation websites in Slovakia, which have been considered dominant tools of Russian media propaganda in the country in recent years. Our findings shed light on the nature of disinformation and pro-Russian narratives during the time of the military conflict in Ukraine, calling for acute and effective solutions that can engage a wide audience as effectively as pro-Russian agents (not only) in Slovakia.
Downloads
References
Abbadia, Jessica (2023, January). Knowledge of narrative analysis. https://mindthegraph.com/blog/sk/narativna-analyza/
American Historical Association (n.d.). Defining Propaganda II. https://www.historians.org/about-aha-and-membership/aha-history-and-archives/gi-roundtable-series/pamphlets/em-2-what-is-propaganda-(1944)/defining-propaganda-ii
Antipropaganda.sk (2021, January). Rusko v slovenskom dezinformačnom priestore [Russia in the Slovak disinformation space]. https://infosecurity.sk/articles/rusko-v-slovenskom-dezinformacnom-priestore-januar-2021/
Bačová, Jana (2023, October). Prvý verdikt v sporoch s dezinfowebmi: Hlavné správy prehrali súd s projektom Konšpirátori.sk [The first verdict in disputes with disinfo websites: Main news lost the court with the project Konspirátori.sk]. https://www.startitup.sk/prvy-verdikt-v-sporoch-s-dezinfowebmi-hlavne-spravy-prehrali-sud-s-projektom-konspiratori-sk/
Bakir, Vian and McStay, Andrew (2018). Fake news and the economy of emotions: Problems, causes, solutions. Digital Journalism, 6(2), 154-175. https://doi.org/10.1080/21670811.2017.1345645
Bánkuty-Balogh, Lilla Sarolta (2021). Novel technologies and geopolitical strategies: Disinformation narratives in the countries of the Visegrád Group. Politics in Central Europe, 17(2), 165-195. https://doi.org/10.2478/pce-2021-0008
Bradshaw, Samantha and Howard, Philip (2018). Challenging truth and trust: A global inventory of organized social media manipulation. University of Oxford.
Council of Europe (2012, December). Russia – Federal laws on the Federal Security Service and extremism. https://www.venice.coe.int/Newsletter/NEWSLETTER_2012_03/1_RUS_EN.html
Das, Manoj (2014). Using Social Networking Sites (SNS): Mediating role of self-disclosure and effect on well-being. Irish Medical Journal, 6(2), 30-38.
Denník N (2017). Klamstvá a konšpirácie: Príručka N pre stredné školy [Lies and conspiracies: A handbook for Secondary Schools]. Vydavateľstvo Denníka N. https://www.vzdelavacisluzby.cz/dokumenty/banka-souboru/5001993.pdf
Denník N (2022, March). Newsfilter: Ruské veľvyslanectvo na Slovensku rovná sa špionáž a šírenie lží [Newsfilter: The Russian embassy in Slovakia is equal to espionage and spreading lies]. https://dennikn.sk/2766225/newsfilter-ruske-velvyslanectvo-na-slovensku-rovna-sa-spionaz-a-sirenie-lzi/
Digital News Report (2020). Foreword to the Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2020. https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/sites/default/files/2020-06/DNR_2020_FINAL.pdf
EEAS Press Team (2023, February). Disinformation: Opening speech by High Representative/Vice-President Josep Borrell at the EEAS Conference on Foreign Information manipulation and interference. https://www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/disinformation-opening-speech-high-representativevice-president-josep-borrell-eeas-conference_en
Embassy of the Russian Federation in the Slovak Republic (2024a, March). Today marks ten years since the historic reunification of Crimea with Russia. https://fb.watch/qU8TcM8Hbo/
Embassy of the Russian Federation in the Slovak Republic (2024b, March). Tvrdenia médií, že za teroristickými útokmi na Nord Streamy stojí s nikým neprepojená„proukrajinská skupina”, sú hlúpou americkou propagandou [Media claims that an unconnected “pro-Ukrainian group” is behind the terrorist attacks on Nord Stream are stupid American propaganda].
European Commission (n.d.). Tackling online disinformation: Shaping Europe’s digital future. https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/
en/policies/online-disinformation
Fitzpatrick, Neill (2018). Media manipulation 2.0: The impact of social media on news, competition, and accuracy. Athens Journal of Mass Media and Communications, 4(1), 45-62. https://doi.org/10.30958/ajmmc.4.1.3
Flintham, Martin; Karner, Christian; Creswick, Helen; Gupta, Neha, and Moran, Stuart (2018). Falling for fake news: Investigating the consumption of news via social media. CHI 2018, April 21-26. 2018, Montreal, QC, Canada, 1-10. https://doi.org/10.1145/3173574.3173950
Galeotti, Mark (2019, June). Active measures: Russia’s covert geopolitical operations. https://www.marshallcenter.org/en/
publications/security-insights/active-measures-russias-covert-geopolitical-operations-0
Hajdari, Una (2023, March). Russian Embassy in Slovakia uses Facebook to push propaganda. Why are so many Slovaks buying it? https://www.euronews.com/2023/03/29/russian-embassy-in-slovakia-uses-facebook-to-push-propaganda-why-are-so-many-slovaks-buyin
Hajdu, Dominika (2022, November). GLOBSEC Trends 2022 – Slovakia. Globsec: Centre for democracy and resilience. https://www.globsec.org/sites/default/files/2022-11/GLOBSEC%20Trends%202022%20Slovakia_0.pdf
Hajdu, Dominika; Klingová, Katarína; Kazaz, Jana; and Kortiš, Michal (2022, May). GLOBSEC Trends 2022: Central and Eastern Europe amid the War in Ukraine. https://www.globsec.org/what-we-do/publications/globsec-trends-2022-central-and-eastern-europe-amid-war-ukraine
Hlavné správy (October 2022). Johnestone: Viem, ako raz a navždy zastaviť Vladimira Putina [Johnestone: I know how to stop Vladimir Putin once and for all]. https://www.hlavnespravy.sk/johnestone-viem-ako-raz-a-navzdy-zastavit-vladimira-putina/2935810
Hlavné správy (2023, October). Ukrajina má veľké obavy [Ukraine is very worried]. https://www.hlavnespravy.sk/ukrajina-ma-velke-obavy/3297502
Hlavné správy (2024, February). Ľuboš Blaha (SMER-SD): “Rusko nie je náš nepriateľ. Pozrite si videozostrih z reportáže ruskej televízie” [Ľuboš Blaha (SMER-SD): “Russia is not our enemy. Watch the video clip from the Russian TV report”]. https://www.hlavnespravy.sk/lubos-blaha-rusko-nie-je-nas-nepriatel-a-ja-urobim-vsetko-pre-mier/3419508
Hutchings, Stephen and Szostek, Joanna (2016). Dominant narratives in Russian political and media discourse during the Ukraine crisis. In Agnieszka Pikulicka-Wilczewska and Richard Sakwa (Eds.). Ukraine and Russia: People, politics, propaganda and perspectives (pp. 173-185). E-International Relations Publishing.
Info vojna (2023, December). Na ukrajinských sociálnych sieťach sa šíra výbušná nahrávka Zelenského a jeho manželky Oleny, kde spolu hovoria o korupcii na Ukrajine. Situácia v Kyjeve je kritická a pokiaľ z USA neprijdou okamžite peniaze na výplaty vojakov, tak ukrajinská armáda prestane bojovať [An explosive recording of Zelensky and his wife Olena talking about corruption in Ukraine is spreading on Ukrainian social networks. The situation in Kyiv is critical, and unless money comes immediately from the US to pay the soldiers, the Ukrainian army will stop fighting]. https://www.infovojna.bz/article/video-britsky-telegraph-napsal-ze-evropa-se-chysta-na-to-ze-ukrajina-valku-prohraje
Info vojna (2024, February). “Posadnutosť Ukrajinou a totálna nenávisť voči Rusku sa každodenne stupňuje. Európska únia svojou pomocou Kyjevu vôbec nehľadí na záujmy svojich členských krajín”, vyhlásil premier Fico [“Obsession with Ukraine and total hatred of Russia is increasing every day. With its help to Kyiv, the European Union does not look at the interests of its member countries at all”, declared Prime Minister Fico]. https://www.infovojna.bz/article/video-posadnutost-ukrajinou-a-totalna-nenavist-voci-rusku-sa-kazdodenne-stupnuje
Ižak, Štefan (2019). (Ab)using the topic of migration by pro Kremlin propaganda: Case study of Slovakia. Journal of Comparative Politics, 12(1), 53-70.
Karlsen, Geir Hågen (2019). Divide and rule: Ten lessons about Russian political influence activities in Europe. Palgrave Communications, 5(19), 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-019-0227-8
Klingová, Katarína (2020, April). Dezinformácie ohrozujú voľby, počas pandémie ohrozujú životy [Disinformation threatens elections, threatens lives during a pandemic]. https://www.globsec.org/what-we-do/commentaries/dezinformacie-ohrozuju-volby-pocas-pandemie-ohrozuju-zivoty
Konšpirátori.sk (n.d.). Zoznam konšpiračných stránok [List of conspiracy sites]. https://konspiratori.sk/zoznam-stranok
Kuczyńska Zonik, Aleksandra and Tatarenko, Agata (2019). Information security risks in the context of Russian propaganda in the CEE. In Anna Visvizi and D. Lytras Miltiadis (Eds.). Politics and technology in the post truth Era (Emerald Studies in Politics and Technology) (pp. 143-157). Emerald Publishing Limited. https://doi.org/10.1108/9781787569836
Litvinenko, Anna (2022). Propaganda on demand: Russia’s media environment during the war in Ukraine. Global Media Journal – German edition, 12(2), 1-14. https://doi.org/10.22032/DBT.55518
Miskimmon, Alister; O’Loughlin, Ben, and Roselle, Laura (2017). Forging the world: Strategic narratives and international relations. University of Michigan Press.
Oxford References (n.d.). Propaganda. https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803100349558
Pivovarov: Editorial office (2023, March). Минобороны России: завершена переброска подразделе [Russian Ministry of Defense: The transfer of subsections has been completed]. https://t.me/redakciya_channel/13420
Poloha, Natanael Leo (2023, March. Zahraničné médiá o Slovensku: Ruská propaganda má Slovákov úplne v hrsti [Foreign media about Slovakia: Russian propaganda has Slovaks completely in their hands]. https://www.startitup.sk/o-slovensku-pisu-v-zahranici-sme-
najslabsia-cast-europy-ruskej-propagande-sa-tu-mimoriadne-dari/
Rechtik, Marek and Mareš, Miroslav (2021). Russian disinformation threat: Comparative case study of Czech and Slovak approaches. Journal of Comparative Politics, 14(1), 4-19.
Reporters Without Borders (2018, October). Slovakia: Press freedom predator’s shadow hangs over Kuciak murder. https://rsf.org/en/slovakia-press-freedom-predator-s-shadow-hangs-over-kuciak-murder
Roselle, Laura; Miskimmon, Alister, and O’Loughlin, Ben (2014). Strategic narrative: A new means to understand soft power. Media, War and Conflict, 7(1), 70-84. https://doi.org/10.1177/1750635213516696
Shultz, H. Richard and Godson, Roy (1984). Dezinformatsia: Active Measures in Soviet Strategy. Pergamon-Brassey’s.
Siwakoti, Samikshya; Yadav, Kamya; Thange, Isra; Bariletto, Nicola; Zanotti, Luca; Ghoneim, Alaa, and Shapiro N. Jacob (2021). Localized misinformation in a global pandemic: Report on COVID-19 narratives around the world. Empirical study of conflict. Princeton University.
Slobodný vysielač (2022a, August). Kovanda: Máte rádi euro? Otevřete Nord Stream 2. Bez něj je měna ztracená [Kovanda: Do you like the euro? Open Nord Stream 2. Without it, the currency is lost]. https://slobodnyvysielac.sk/clanky/kovanda-mate-radi-euro-otevrete-nord-stream-2-bez-nej-je-mena-ztracena/
Slobodný vysielač (2022b, February). Blaha priblížil fungovanie zahraničných agentov na Slovensku: “S príchodom novej vlády budeme musieť urobiť veľký prievan v liberálnych mimovládnych organizáciách. V minulosti sme boli príliš mäkkí. Bola to chyba” [Blaha elaborated on the functioning of foreign agents in Slovakia: “With the arrival of the new government, we will have to make a big move in liberal non-governmental organizations. We were too soft in the past. It was a mistake”]. https://slobodnyvysielac.sk/clanky/blaha-
priblizil-fungovanie-zahranicnych-agentov-na-slovensku-s-prichodom-novej-vlady-budeme-musiet-urobit-velky-prievan-v-liberalnych-mimovladnych-organizaciach-v-minulosti-sme-boli-prilis/
Slobodný vysielač (2023, June). Ukrajina prohrává a v Evropě s prázdnými vojenskými sklady vládne panika [Ukraine is losing and panic is reigning in Europe with empty military warehouses]. https://slobodnyvysielac.sk/clanky/ukrajina-prohrava-a-v-evrope-s-prazdnymi-vojenskymi-sklady-vladne-panika/
Slobodný vysielač (2024, January). Ukrajina prohrává a v Evropě s prázdnými vojenskými sklady vládne panika [Ukraine is losing and panic is reigning in Europe with empty military warehouses]. https://slobodnyvysielac.sk/clanky/sachs-vojnu-na-ukrajine-vyprovokovala-amerika-mier-sa-neda-dosiahnut-zbranami/
Slovak Academy of Sciences (2020, December). Názory na konšpirácie o epidémii koronavírusu [Opinions on conspiracies about the coronavirus epidemic]. https://www.sav.sk/index.php?doc=services-newsandsource_no=20andnews_no=9192
Slovak Archive of Social Data (2020, April). Ako sa máte, Slovensko? [How are you, Slovakia?] https://sasd.sav.sk/sk/data_katalog_
abs.php?id=sasd_2020002
Šnídl, Vladimír (2018, October). Prehliadaní spojenci Kočnera: Hlavné správy, Slobodný vysielač a Vaský s Daňom [Overlooked allies of Kočner: Hlavné právé, Slobodný váchtač and Vaský s Daňom]. https://dennikn.sk/1263105/prehliadani-spojenci-kocnera-hlavne-spravy-slobodny-vysielac-a-vasky-s-danom/
Šnídl, Vladimír (2019, April). Prokremeľskú propagandu na Facebooku najviac šírili Hlavné správy a Slobodný vysielač [Pro-Kremlin propaganda on Facebook was spread the most by Hlavné správy and Slobodný vysielač]. https://dennikn.sk/1446366/prokremelsku-propagandu-na-facebooku-najviac-sirili-hlavne-spravy-a-slobodny-vysielac/
Šnídl, Vladimír (2023, March. Ruská ambasáda na Slovensku je na Facebooku nejakčnější v Evropě. Válku obhajuje i v konspiračních médiích [The Russian Embassy in Slovakia is the most active on Facebook in Europe. He also defends the war in conspiracy media]. https://denikn.cz/1103215/ruska-ambasada-na-slovensku-je-na-facebooku-nejakcnejsi-v-evrope-valku-obhajuje-i-v-konspiracnich-mediich/
Statpol (2020, September). Súčasné trendy šírenia dezinformácií [Current trends in the spread of disinformation]. https://stratpol.sk/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/publi-trendy-%C5%A1%C3%ADrenia-dezinform%C3%A1ci%C3%AD2.pdf
Struhárik, Filip (2019, October). MediaBrífing: Prečo sú Hlavné správy ideálnym partnerom pre Fica a Kočnera [MediaBriefing: Why Hlavné sravé is an ideal partner for Fico and Kočner]. https://dennikn.sk/1630470/mediabrifing-preco-su-hlavne-spravy-idealny-partner-pre-fica-a-kocnera-grafy-a-fakty/
Thesaurus.com (n.d.). Propaganda. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/propaganda;
Uhlárik, Jozef (2023, June). Ruská propaganda a jej príklady. Cieli na nerozhodných [Russian propaganda and its examples. It goals on ties]. https://sita.sk/ruska-propaganda-cieli-na-nerozhodnych-varuje-policia-a-uvadza-viacere-priklady/
Wenzel, Michał; Stasiuk-Krajewska, Karina; Macková, Veronika, and Turková, Kateřina. (2024). The penetration of Russian disinformation in connection with the war in Ukraine: Evidence from Poland, the Czech Republic and Slovakia. International Political Science Review, 45(2), 192-208. https://doi.org/10.1177/01925121231205259
Zem a vek (2022, July). Ruská Amerika [Russian America]. https://zemavek.sk/ruska-amerika/
Zem a vek (2023, July). Chmelár: Solženicyn vedel, k čomu povedie expanzia NATO [Chmelár: Solzhenitsyn knew what NATO expansion would lead to]. https://zemavek.sk/chmelar-solzenicyn-vedel-k-comu-povedie-expanzia-nato/
Zem a vek (2024, March). Sergej Naryškin: Rusko vyhrá nad kolektívnym Západom vo chvíli, keď budú oslobodení všetci, ktorí chcú byť oslobodení! [Sergey Naryshkin: Russia will win over the collective West at the moment when all those who want to be freed will be freed!]. https://zemavek.sk/sergej-naryskin-rusko-vyhra-nad-kolektivnym-zapadom-vo-chvili-ked-budu-oslobodeni-vsetci-ktori-chcu-byt-oslobodeni/
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Tripodos
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Once an article has been approved for publication in Tripodos, the exclusive right to publish the work becomes the property of Blanquerna School of Communication and International Relations of Ramon Llull University. These rights can be granted to a third party with the agreement of the author(s).
Until the articles have been approved for publication, Blanquerna School of Communication and International Relations of Ramon Llull University has no rights over them.
The submission of articles is understood to represent explicit consent to these conditions of publication.
